The Numbers Buyers Check First
By Matt Behrens, Managing Partner | 6 min read
Investors love a good growth story. A founder who built a brand from a kitchen table, or a product that took off on social media, gets our attention. But the story is only the hook. Once we are in the room, we move quickly to a handful of numbers that tell us whether the growth is real, whether it is profitable, and whether it can be repeated. Owners who know those numbers before the conversation starts are in a much stronger position.
Measure customer acquisition against contribution, not sales
This is the mistake we see most often. A brand sells a product for $100, pays $50 in variable costs, and spends $75 to acquire the customer. Many teams present that as a return of $100 divided by $75, or 1.33. The real number is $50 of contribution divided by $75, or 0.67. The first figure says the marketing is working. The second says each customer loses money on the first sale. Brands that use gross sales as the numerator tend to overspend on marketing that is not actually effective. Always calculate CAC against contribution after every variable cost, including product, freight, fulfillment, payment processing, and discounts.
Do not blend channels together
A common practice, often encouraged by agencies, is to combine results across email, SMS, and paid social into one marketing number. That hides the truth. Email and SMS are usually far more efficient than paid media, but blending the results inflates the cost of the expensive channels and drags down the efficient ones. Track acquisition cost, payback period, and contribution by channel, then make allocation decisions based on each channel’s own numbers.
Be careful with blended return metrics like MER
Marketing efficiency ratio, or MER, divides total revenue by total marketing spend. It combines new customers with existing ones, so a loyal subscriber who reorders every month can make the total look strong even when the marketing that brings in new customers is weak. Ask separately how much revenue came from new customers and what each new customer cost.
Use cohort analysis to see how customers behave over time
We prefer cohort analysis: group customers by the month or quarter they were acquired, then track how each group buys over time. Are customers acquired in the most recent quarter returning at the same rate as customers acquired a year ago? If newer cohorts retain worse, the growth may be coming from paid acquisition that does not build a lasting customer base.
Know your inventory and cash conversion
A brand that turns inventory quickly needs less capital to grow. Slow-moving stock ties up cash and often leads to markdowns that erode margin. Show how long it takes to convert inventory into cash, and how that has changed over the last year.
Understand channel concentration
If most revenue comes from one retailer, one marketplace, or one customer segment, a buyer will price that risk into the offer. You do not need to be perfectly diversified, but you should know your concentration and have a plan for any dependency that is too large.
How to prepare
Build a simple dashboard that tracks these measures monthly and update it consistently. Show contribution-based CAC and payback by channel, cohort retention curves for each acquisition period, contribution margin, inventory turns, and channel concentration. Keep the definitions the same over time. A clean and honest set of figures does more for credibility than any polished presentation. If a number is weak, explain what you are doing about it. Buyers respect owners who understand their own business.
The brands that attract the best partners are rarely the ones with the most impressive headline growth. They are the ones whose owners can explain, clearly and with data, where their customers come from, what each one is worth, and whether the business gets stronger as it grows.